Daniel Deronda

by

George Eliot

Daniel Deronda: Chapter 17 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
On a warm evening in late July, Daniel rows his boat along the Thames, seeking solitude. A year has passed since he returned to England with his formal education completed, yet he remains uncertain about his future. In deference to Sir Hugo’s wishes, he has begun studying law, but this only deepens his indecision. Boating has become his refuge, offering him the stillness to contemplate his direction in life.
Daniel’s solitary rowing reflects his growing uncertainty about his future. Though he has completed his formal education, he remains unfulfilled. Studying law is a concession to Sir Hugo’s expectations rather than a true calling. The act of rowing provides a temporary escape from these pressures, allowing him to contemplate his direction in life.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon
As he rows beneath Kew Bridge, Daniel sings softly to himself. The melancholy melody floats across the water, unnoticed by most. However, on the riverbank, a young woman appears deeply affected by it. Daniel’s gaze falls on her: a delicate, dark-haired girl (later revealed to be Mirah Lapidoth), dressed simply, standing with an expression of profound despair. Her hands are clasped, her eyes fixed on the water with an almost statue-like stillness. He stops singing as their eyes meet in an intense, searching look. She does not react with alarm but rather a dazed kind of recognition before turning away to sit on a nearby bench. Daniel feels an immediate surge of compassion but hesitates to intrude upon her sorrow. Reasoning that he has no right to impose, he rows away, yet the image of her desolate figure lingers in his mind.
Mirah’s presence disrupts Daniel’s solitude in a way he does not yet understand. Her motionless despair makes her seem almost like an apparition, set apart from the world around her. Their silent exchange carries an unusual intensity. She does not react with alarm, nor does he immediately intervene. His hesitation is telling; though deeply compassionate, he respects personal boundaries and does not assume the right to impose himself on another’s sorrow. Yet as he rows away, her image lingers in his mind, a sign that their encounter has unsettled him on a level beyond simple sympathy.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon
Quotes
Continuing up the river, Daniel cannot shake the impression Mirah left on him. He wonders what misfortune has led to such despair. Later, as he finds a secluded spot near Kew Gardens to rest, something catches his eye on the opposite bank. Mirah stands by the water’s edge, hidden among willow trees. She removes her hat, then deliberately dips her cloak into the river, soaking it. Watching her, Daniel suddenly realizes her intention: she means to wrap herself in the wet fabric before drowning. Without hesitation, he seizes his oar and rows toward her. Startled, she crouches in fear, clutching the heavy cloak as if trying to make herself invisible. As Daniel reaches her, he speaks gently, reassuring her of his good intentions.
When Daniel realizes Mirah’s intent to drown herself, his passive concern transforms into immediate action. His instinct to save her is not calculated but urgent, an extension of his fundamental need to help others. Mirah’s reaction—trying to make herself invisible—shows that she has accepted her fate to the point that even being noticed feels unnatural.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon
Mirah, still shaken, lifts her head and meets his gaze. Recognition flickers in her eyes. She remembers his song, associating it with her own sorrow. Daniel, moved and troubled, persuades her to trust him. Though she hesitates, she finally allows him to help her into the boat. He retrieves her hat and wrings out her cloak, suggesting that they take it with them so no one assumes she has drowned. To reassure her, he offers his coat, which she accepts with a faint, melancholy smile.
Daniel’s approach remains gentle, allowing her to recognize that he is not an intruder but someone who genuinely cares whether she lives or dies.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon
Judaism and Zionism Theme Icon
Get the entire Daniel Deronda LitChart as a printable PDF.
Daniel Deronda PDF
As they glide across the water, Daniel refrains from pressing Mirah with questions, hoping she will speak when ready. At last, she breaks the silence, saying she would have been dead had he not arrived. She confesses her despair, explaining that she has nowhere to go and no one to turn to. When Daniel asks if she is English, she hesitates before replying, “I am English-born. But I am a Jewess.” The admission is cautious, almost fearful. Daniel reassures her that he does not judge her for it. She seems relieved but remains haunted by the loss of her family—her mother and brother, whom she cannot find.
The conversation in the boat reveals Mirah’s deep fear of rejection. Her admission of being Jewish is hesitant, as if she expects that even her rescuer might judge her for it. Daniel’s lack of prejudice sets him apart from the world she has known, allowing her a rare moment of relief. The loss of her family weighs on her, making her feel rootless, much like Daniel himself. Though their experiences differ, the theme of displacement links them, creating an emotional bond before either of them fully understands its significance.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon
Judaism and Zionism Theme Icon
As Mirah weeps, Daniel realizes he cannot take her to Sir Hugo’s grand household, where she might face suspicion or indifference. Instead, he decides to bring her to Mrs. Meyrick’s home in Chelsea, where he knows she will find warmth and kindness. During the cab ride to Chelsea, the girl dozes fitfully, her head lolling with exhaustion. As Daniel watches her, he wonders about the life she has fled. He recalls an old story of Delphic women who protected lost strangers, standing guard as they slept. He finds comfort in the thought that the Meyricks will do the same. Yet a deeper anxiety lingers: he has rescued her from death, but what if he cannot truly save her?
Daniel’s choice to bring Mirah to Mrs. Meyrick’s home rather than Sir Hugo’s estate demonstrates his understanding of the social dynamics at play. He knows that the Meyricks will treat her with warmth and kindness, something a grand aristocratic household might lack. This decision reinforces Daniel’s growing belief that true security comes not from wealth or status, but from genuine human connection. He acts with careful consideration, ensuring that Mirah’s rescue is not just about saving her life but about placing her somewhere she can begin to rebuild it. The imagery of the Delphic women guarding lost strangers connects Daniel’s actions to an older, mythic tradition of protection and hospitality. However, it also exposes his underlying anxiety. He has saved Mirah from immediate danger, but he cannot guarantee her future. His idealism is tempered by the knowledge that rescue is not the same as salvation. This uncertainty mirrors his own struggle—just as he questions his own purpose, he wonders whether his actions will truly help Mirah or if she will remain lost despite his intervention.
Themes
Identity and Self-Discovery Theme Icon