Previous
Part 3, Chapter 4
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Atlas Shrugged, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
The Morality of Self-Interest
The Value of Productive Work
The Individual vs. the Collective
Government Power and Corruption
The Corruption of Language
Despair in the Absence of Purpose
Summary
Analysis
On the morning of September 2, a crucial copper wire snaps in California, halting operations along the Pacific branch of Taggart Transcontinental. The local workers are unable to replace it due to a national copper shortage, worsened by government mismanagement and cronyism. One roadmaster manages to contact Dagny privately, bypassing the bureaucrats. She quickly diverts a shipment of wire from Montana to prevent a total shutdown of the Pacific Line, which remains critical to the country’s oil supply. Yet even this emergency fix reveals how fragile the system has become, with resources hoarded or rerouted based on political pull rather than need.
The snapping copper wire symbolizes the fragile nature of an economy crippled by governmental corruption and inefficiency. Dagny’s emergency actions to reroute resources show the difficulty of preserving rational production in an environment governed by political favoritism rather than competence. Her effort is a small, temporary fix to a systemic breakdown—an attempt to uphold order and productivity in the face of irrationality.
Themes
Dagny returns to New York and finds James waiting in her office. Since Cherryl’s death, James has taken to lingering near Dagny, hovering with a kind of aimless desperation. He seeks absolution but never speaks of guilt. During their meeting, James criticizes her for being uncooperative since her return, accusing her of undermining the Unification Plan and of failing to support him as her weaker sibling. Disgusted, Dagny tells him he and the other looters should simply give up. As he rants, he insists she stay and listen to a broadcast from Santiago. The radio announcer declares that, as the nationalization of d’Anconia Copper passed, every property belonging to the company worldwide was simultaneously destroyed. Additionally, Francisco has vanished.
James’s presence after Cherryl’s death embodies his emotional dependence and persistent need for validation despite his failures. His accusations against Dagny reveal his deep insecurity and resentment toward her strength and capability. Francisco’s simultaneous destruction of d’Anconia Copper illustrates the definitive refusal of productive individuals to sustain a corrupt system, confirming the scale and intent of the intellectual strike.
Themes
Shaken but also strangely relieved, Dagny goes to meet Hank for dinner. They have been meeting regularly in public, and their dinners have become a quiet act of defiance. The broadcast confirms what they suspected: Francisco and Ragnar were working together. Dagny tells Hank that Francisco is one of the destroyer’s agents, and Hank confesses that he is relieved to know someone had come for Ken Danagger when he disappeared. Their conversation turns to the coming winter. Farmers in Minnesota have produced a large wheat crop, but without railcars to transport it, the food will rot. Dagny and Hank agree to try to keep the country alive at least through one more season.
Dagny and Hank’s quiet defiance through their public meetings shows their resolve to maintain dignity amid societal collapse. Their acknowledgment of Francisco and Ragnar’s actions demonstrates their alignment with the strikers’ moral stance, even as they remain committed to supporting society. The impending ruin of Minnesota’s wheat crop represents the tangible human cost of systemic incompetence and corruption, highlighting their desperate effort to save a crumbling world.
Themes
Back in New York, Hank finds himself courted by Washington officials. This sudden friendliness alarms him. Meanwhile, his brother Philip appears at the mills asking for a job. Philip insists he deserves one because of their family connection and Hank’s success. Hank refuses, explaining that Philip has no skills and that he will not hand out jobs as charity. Philip tries to guilt him and even hints at government intervention, but Hank stands firm. The encounter solidifies the moral line Hank now draws, rejecting all claims based on need and entitlement in favor of ability and earned value.
Philip’s demand for employment based solely on family ties exemplifies the moral inversion prevalent in the novel’s collapsing society. Hank’s firm refusal asserts a fundamental moral principle—jobs and resources must be earned through skill and merit, not entitlement. His rejection of Philip’s appeals is part of his commitment to rational productivity and integrity against growing governmental pressures.
Themes
Get the entire Atlas Shrugged LitChart as a printable PDF.
Hank also hears from the Wet Nurse. The boy now confesses he wants a real job at the mills, even if it is only janitorial. Hank declines, knowing it would put them both in danger due to the political eyes on the mills. The Wet Nurse confirms that Washington is preparing something behind Hank’s back—likely new restrictions or personnel changes. Hank realizes the government is already slipping its own thugs into his workforce under the guise of regulation. Meanwhile, Hank’s divorce is quietly finalized. Though legally free, he feels more estranged from society than ever.
The Wet Nurse’s confession reveals a shift in his own moral perspective, reflecting his recognition of Hank’s integrity. His warning about Washington’s looming actions emphasizes the insidious nature of government interference, concealing destructive intentions behind regulatory language. Hank’s divorce symbolizes his final detachment from a society that has lost touch with reason, leaving him isolated but morally resolute.
Themes
As Dagny tries to keep the railroad functioning, she is informed that the freight cars needed to collect Minnesota’s wheat crop were diverted. Cuffy Meigs sent them to Louisiana for a soybean experiment sponsored by the mother of a politician. The wheat sits in the fields, and there are no cars to move it. Panic sets in. Farmers try to transport the crop themselves, hijack vehicles, or abandon their farms. Fighting breaks out. Meanwhile, the soybeans were harvested prematurely and rot just as the wheat does. With both crops ruined, a national famine is now certain. The farming economy in Minnesota collapses overnight.
The diversion of freight cars from essential wheat to politically favored soybean experiments illustrates the catastrophic consequences of arbitrary power. The collapse of Minnesota’s farming economy shows how quickly irrational decisions can devastate productive sectors. The resulting panic and violence demonstrate that government’s disregard for reality directly leads to societal breakdown and widespread suffering.
Themes
Dagny is summoned to a meeting of railroad executives and government officials. The men at the table include Ferris, Mouch, Meigs, Lawson, Weatherby, and James. They ask Dagny which lines to cut, since the railroad cannot be maintained in its entirety. She refuses to sacrifice Minnesota, knowing it supplies both grain and iron ore to the East. The others, more concerned with political image than logistical survival, push to keep symbolic lines running instead. Dagny realizes with horror that they are trying to revert society to a pre-industrial age, where force and faith rule over reason. Her ability to keep the railroad alive dwindles daily.
Dagny’s confrontation with the railroad executives and government officials reveals their dangerous detachment from practical reality. Their insistence on symbolic rather than functional lines indicates an alarming preference for appearances over survival. Dagny sees clearly that their goal is not merely incompetence but the deliberate dismantling of industrial civilization, choosing force and symbolism over logic and life.
Themes
That night, disaster strikes at the Taggart Terminal. A copper wire breaks in the control tower, knocking out the interlocking signal system. With no one able to fix the problem, the terminal grinds to a halt. Dagny takes charge. She orders a return to manual operation: workers will stand in tunnels with lanterns, relaying instructions like in the early days of rail. As she addresses her employees, she suddenly spots a familiar face among the crowd. It’s John Galt. The sight of him catches her off guard, and she walks into the tunnels. As she expected, he follows.
The breakdown at Taggart Terminal, forcing a return to manual operations, represents a symbolic regression to pre-industrial conditions. Dagny’s rapid response demonstrates her enduring commitment to maintaining functional order even in desperate circumstances. Seeing John Galt unexpectedly amid this chaos brings into sharp relief the tension between her duty to the collapsing world and her personal desire.
Themes
In a secluded part of the tunnel, Dagny and Galt fall into each other’s arms and have sex on a stack of sandbags. Afterward, he confesses everything. He has worked at Taggart Transcontinental for 12 years in a menial role, watching Dagny and loving her from afar. He tells her he does suffer but insists pain is something to be fought, not accepted as part of the soul. He praises her radio speech and says he is not jealous of her relationship with Hank. She tells him she loves him. However, Galt warns her not to seek him out again.
Dagny’s encounter with Galt in the tunnel culminates years of implicit attraction and intellectual alignment. Galt’s confession that he has loved Dagny from afar introduces the deeply personal cost of his philosophical mission. Galt and Dagny’s union, amid the darkness and collapse around them, embodies the human capacity for connection and affirmation of life even within a collapsing moral landscape.
Themes
Galt explains that if the looters find him, they will kill him. If Dagny ever truly decides to abandon their world, she can signal him by drawing a dollar sign on the base of Nat Taggart’s statue. He promises to come for her within 24 hours. Until then, they must remain apart. Dagny understands the stakes but feels gutted. Galt disappears into the dark, and she returns to her duties, her love for him competing with the impossible burden she still carries.
Galt’s warning about their necessary separation highlights the harsh realities of the ideological conflict playing out in the world: love and rationality cannot thrive in a society dominated by destructive forces. Meanwhile, Dagny’s return to her duties emphasizes the painful balance she must maintain between personal happiness and her remaining sense of professional responsibility.
Themes
