Previous
Part 1, Chapter 5
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Atlas Shrugged, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
The Morality of Self-Interest
The Value of Productive Work
The Individual vs. the Collective
Government Power and Corruption
The Corruption of Language
Despair in the Absence of Purpose
Summary
Analysis
On the night of his wedding anniversary, Hank Rearden stands before his bedroom mirror, trying to prepare for the party Lillian is hosting. He presses his forehead to the glass, trying to calm the storm in his head. He had forgotten about the event until his secretary reminded him half an hour ago. The thought of spending hours making small talk with people he has nothing in common with fills him with exhaustion and dread. Hank reflects on his failures as a husband. His family constantly tells him he only cares about work, and he has never denied it. He knows Lillian wants more from him—something beyond business—but he does not know how to give it. He feels no guilt about this, only a sense of duty that he no longer understands.
Hank’s dread before the party shows the widening gap between personal performance and meaningful action—he’d rather . The mirror becomes a symbol of self-interrogation, not vanity—he is searching for a reflection he cannot find. His feeling of duty, now drained of meaning, contrasts with the precise sense of purpose that drives his work. Unlike Dagny, who finds energy in building, Hank finds only exhaustion in navigating social rituals that demand nothing and reward less.
Themes
Business problems crowd Hank’s mind: a superintendent just quit, a ship carrying ore sank, copper supplies are uncertain, and an urgent deal in Detroit needs attention. But to his family, these things are meaningless—just another excuse to call him cold. He glances at a newspaper clipping his secretary gave him: it is about the Equalization of Opportunity Bill, a new law that would prevent anyone from owning multiple businesses. Hank’s Washington man, Wesley Mouch, told him that it won’t pass. Still, Hank is disturbed that such a law is even being considered. He crumples the paper in disgust.
The piling business problems emphasize the intensity of Hank’s real responsibilities, which are invisible to his family and the world they inhabit. The Equalization of Opportunity Bill suggests that society has moved beyond misunderstanding free market capitalism—it now wants to punish it. The proposed law targets achievement at its root: ownership. That Mouch downplays its threat foreshadows events that occur later in the novel.
Themes
Dressed for the party, Hank walks downstairs. At the bottom of the staircase, he sees Lillian. Dressed in an expensive gown, she looks beautiful and confident. On one wrist, she wears diamonds. On the other, she wears the bracelet he made from the first batch of Rearden Metal. The contrast between the two pieces of jewelry startles him. He realizes she is wearing the bracelet to mock him.
The contrast between the Rearden Metal bracelet and Lillian’s diamonds exposes two conflicting value systems. The diamonds represent tradition, status, and inherited meaning; the bracelet embodies earned value and creation. Lillian’s use of the Rearden Metal bracelet as mockery perverts its original purpose, turning an act of love and pride into a public humiliation.
Themes
Wealthy guests engaged in pretentious conversation file in, and the party begins. Dr. Pritchett, a philosopher, declares that life has no meaning and that reason is a myth. Balph Eubank, a failed author, insists that literature should show life as hopeless and ugly. Bertram Scudder, a magazine editor, rails against property rights and claims the rich should be stripped of their wealth. They all speak with smug certainty, celebrating failure and weakness as moral ideals. Hank listens silently, sickened by their words.
The guests’ declarations—celebrating irrationality, failure, and the destruction of wealth—solidify the novel’s picture of cultural suicide. These are not fringe views; they are the dominant moral narrative among elites. The party becomes a showcase of the intellectual rot Hank has always ignored but now must face. That these people speak with such certainty reveals a world that has rejected thinking in favor of slogans.
Themes
Get the entire Atlas Shrugged LitChart as a printable PDF.
Dagny arrives, stunning in a sleek black gown. Lillian greets her with polished condescension, pretending to be surprised by Dagny’s appearance. Dagny senses the hostility but ignores it, looking for Hank. When she finds him, he is cold and distant, unwilling to speak. It confuses her—he was open with her during their last meeting, and now he seems like a stranger.
Dagny’s arrival adds a jolt of vitality to the hollow room. Lillian’s condescension fails to provoke her because Dagny recognizes the power dynamics at play; Lillian has only social weapons, not substance. Hank’s coldness confuses Dagny because it violates the unspoken trust between them, built on mutual respect. His emotional withdrawal speaks to the pressure he feels from all directions.
Themes
Francisco d’Anconia arrives, and Hank is immediately repelled. He sees Francisco as a disgrace—someone who squandered his fortune and betrayed his potential. But Francisco approaches politely and asks if Hank would prefer him to leave. Surprised by the respect, Hank tells him to stay. Francisco replies that he came specifically to meet Hank, hinting that they have more in common than Hank thinks. Hank lashes out, calling Francisco a fraud and a traitor. Francisco accepts the insult calmly and refuses to explain himself.
Francisco’s entrance draws out Hank’s unresolved disgust—not only with Francisco, but with any sign of squandered greatness. Their exchange is layered: Francisco tests Hank’s mind while Hank lashes out with moral instinct. Francisco’s willingness to absorb insults without defense is strategic, as he is drawing Hank toward a deeper understanding of the world’s moral crisis. His statement that they have more in common hints at shared values buried under misunderstanding. But Hank, still chained to surface judgments, cannot yet see what connects them.
Themes
Dagny walks past a group of guests huddled near an unlit fireplace. Though the room is not cold, they sit close together, as if drawing comfort from a fire that does not exist. The conversation drifts from a general fear of night to rumors of Ragnar Danneskjöld, a pirate who has been attacking government ships. One woman claims to have heard gunfire the night before, which others say was the Coast Guard trying to catch him. They share stories of his mysterious ship, his background, and sightings across the Atlantic.
The group’s huddle around a dead fireplace acts as a metaphor for their spiritual emptiness. Though there is no physical cold, they behave as if they need warmth—a ritual of comfort rather than necessity. The pirate stories signal both fear and fascination with someone who is willing to violently stand up to the government.
Themes
As the group speaks, their tone grows more uncertain and resigned. One woman mentions that she doesn’t know what’s right anymore. Another responds, “Who is John Galt?” and then claims she knows the answer. She tells Dagny a strange story about a millionaire who found the lost city of Atlantis beneath the ocean. Francisco d’Anconia, standing nearby, listens silently. When the woman insists the story is true, he steps forward and says that she was telling the truth—without knowing it. Dagny turns on him, demanding to know what he finds so amusing. Francisco looks at her body and says, “Dagny, what a magnificent waste.” She blushes, then turns and runs.
The woman’s Atlantis story, mixed with the legend of John Galt, shows how myths replace facts when people can no longer reason. Francisco’s comment—that her story is true without her knowing it—unsettles Dagny because it implies that meaning still exists beneath the noise. His remark about Dagny’s body stuns her because it cuts to the heart of her fear: that all her strength and clarity may go to waste in a world that doesn’t deserve it. Francisco isn’t mocking her—he’s mourning what the world may do to her.
Themes
As Dagny reenters the main room, she hears Lillian laughing and holding up the bracelet Hank made for her. Lillian calls it a chain and mocks it in front of the other guests. Without hesitation, Dagny walks over, removes her diamond bracelet, and offers to trade it for Lillian’s. Lillian agrees, thinking Dagny has made a fool of herself. Hank watches the exchange without speaking, then walks over and kisses Lillian’s hand.
The bracelet exchange reclaims meaning through action. Dagny’s trade is a direct challenge to Lillian’s false values. By accepting the chain and discarding the diamonds, Dagny affirms that creation matters more than status. Lillian misunderstands the gesture as foolish because she cannot conceive of value apart from appearances. Hank’s silent witness and kiss on Lillian’s hand betray his inner fracture: he plays the role expected of him, even as he knows it contradicts everything he believes.
Themes
Hank stays by Lillian’s side for the rest of the evening, playing the role of the dutiful husband. Late that night, after the guests are gone, he enters Lillian’s bedroom—something he rarely does. They talk idly about the party. Their conversation is empty, made of small talk and polite lies. He asks why she married him. She evades the question and laughs. He tells her to stick to her own kind next time she throws a party. She laughs again. Hank leaves the room without an answer, still wondering what she wants from him and why he ever thought he could give it.
This scene between Hank and Lillian portrays a marriage that functions on denial. Their conversation is a performance of intimacy that conceals the relationship’s underlying superficiality. Hank’s direct question about why she married him cuts through the fog, but Lillian’s evasions signal that truth has no place in their relationship. Hank walks away knowing that no reconciliation is possible, only the management of appearances.
Themes
