One Day

by

David Nicholls

One Day: Chapter 10 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Monday, July 15, 1996. Emma and Mr. Godalming are half undressed on the floor of his office. They’ve just had sex, but Emma finds that even sex sometimes leaves her in a bad mood. It’s the end of the term, and the building is otherwise deserted. Mr. Godalming says he doesn’t know how he’ll last six weeks of summer without Emma. She suggests he can always fall back on his wife, but he doesn’t appreciate her humor. To try to lighten the mood, she suggests that he should use the summer to experiment with getting rid of his beard, but he seems very attached to it.
Emma has judged Dexter for his many shallow relationships, but now she has to face the idea that she herself is involved in a morally dubious affair, with her cheating on Ian for part of the affair and with Mr. Godalming cheating on his wife. This passage portrays Mr. Godalming as a serious and even humorless man, which might help explain why Emma would want him as a refuge from Ian.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Emma’s affair with her boss, Mr. Godalming, began the previous September, shortly after Emma turned down a proposal from Ian. One day, she burst into tears in Mr. Godalming’s office, and he comforted her and took her to dinner, where they got very drunk and had sex afterward. For Christmas, Mr. Godalming gave Emma a cell phone. She said she liked it, but it meant she lost a bet. At times, Emma wondered if she loved Mr. Godalming, but now, nine months later, she isn’t sure what she’s doing.
Ian’s proposal, while poorly conceived, nevertheless forced Emma to consider their relationship seriously and ultimately reject him. Still, though she takes action in this scene, Emma still seems to be living passively overall. Nothing about Mr. Godalming suggests that he is a better fit than Ian for Emma, as she once again finds herself involved with someone she doesn’t love.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
As Mr. Godalming is about to leave for the holiday, Emma admits that she doesn’t feel excited about the affair anymore. He gets angry and says that she has terrible timing and they should discuss it again at the beginning of the school year. Emma wants to stop. Mr. Godalming raises the possibility of telling his wife, but Emma says she doesn’t want that. At last, they agree to “pencil-in” a meeting for next term, and he leaves, then Emma leaves 20 minutes later.
Emma’s relationship with Mr. Godalming seems to follow many of the same beats as her relationship with Ian, with Mr. Godalming’s offer to tell his wife being similar to Ian’s marriage proposal. The fact that Mr. Godalming gets Emma to “pencil-in” a discussion about their affair shows the passionless, businesslike way they now go about things.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Ian has moved out of the flat, but he’s back when Emma returns. He claims he’s just back to get more of his things, but Emma accuses him of finding excuses to spy on her. He hasn’t shaved or washed recently. He thinks Emma was with someone recently, but Emma says she’s just getting back from play rehearsals. Ian insists that she must have broken up with him because she has a new boyfriend. At last, Emma says she’d been having sex with Mr. Godalming for nine months, but she says it so dryly that he assumes she’s joking. Ian says his own theory is that it must be Dexter.
While Emma struggles to get out of her unfulfilling relationship with Mr. Godalming, Ian meanwhile struggles to get over a relationship with Emma that will never work out. When Emma says that she’s been having sex with Mr. Godalming for nine months and Ian takes it as a joke, this shows how little he really knows about her, even as he claims to love her.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Get the entire One Day LitChart as a printable PDF.
One Day PDF
Ian admits that he’s read some of Emma’s notebooks over the years, including about her time with Dexter in Greece. Emma gets outraged. She tries to kick Ian out. He says it’s his flat too, but she reminds him he never paid mortgage. She says she’s never really been happy in the flat. Ian asks why she can’t just love him again, but Emma says it’s not possible and wants his keys back. Ian apologizes again for rifling through Emma’s notebooks but says that some of her stories are good and she should send them out eventually. She promises to eventually.
Ian’s reading of Emma’s notebooks is a big invasion of privacy, showing how he doesn’t respect or trust Emma. His actions confirm the doubts that Emma had about the relationship, although Emma herself had her own secrets, like her relationship with Dr. Godalming. In spite of Ian’s violation of trust, his encouragement of Emma to write is important because it’s one of the first times someone has supported this specific interest of hers so directly. 
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Ian asks one more time about Dexter, who supposedly broke up with Suki recently, and Emma says she hasn’t seen him in a long time. Emma insists that she and Dexter were just friends. She tells Ian that one day he’ll feel better. Eventually, he seems to accept this and leave, saying he still thinks Emma is The Bollocks.
In spite of Ian’s stubbornness earlier, in this passage he seems to show some ability to change as he slowly accepts his and Emma’s breakup. Ian’s ability to grow foreshadows how Dexter himself will eventually lose some of his childish tendencies.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Emma decides to get drunk. She goes to a shop and buys expensive old champagne and some cigarettes. As she walks back, she is surprised to run into Sonya, who has grown up since she was in Oliver! and is now in her first year of college, preparing for A-levels, then hopefully to a more prestigious university. The whole time, Emma hides her lit cigarette.
In the UK, “college” often refers to vocational or remedial courses while “university” refers to advanced degrees like bachelor of arts and masters’ degrees. Basically, Sonya is trying to get into a university through a path that is common for lower-income students, reflecting her working-class status that causes children to make fun of her during Oliver!
Themes
Social Class Theme Icon
Coming of Age and the Search for Meaning   Theme Icon
Addiction and Recovery Theme Icon
Quotes
Emma goes home and drinks the bottle, then she falls half-asleep. She wakes however, when she hears Dexter’s voice. He’s now on a late-night television show about videogames. She thinks he’s looking a little tired and unhealthy these days, but for some reason, she feels affection toward him again, and she decides to call him the next day.
As Emma is drunk and only half-awake, she in many ways begins to resemble Dexter at his worst moments. Although Emma thinks Dexter looks worse on TV, she’s well aware of the way that her own life has come up short on her goals, which is perhaps why she begins to feel more sympathetic toward him.
Themes
Relationships and Time Theme Icon
Addiction and Recovery Theme Icon