Luis does not like the story of Juan because Juan seems nothing like the priests Luis has met such as the whisky priest and Padré Jose. The whisky priest and Padré Jose are flawed and complicated men, while Juan is the perfect servant of God. As such, the stories of Juan do not appear to comport with Luis’s real life. Luis’s mother does not shy away from the complexities of real life, but she still wants to present an idealized version of Catholicism to her children. However, as her husband points out, Padré Jose and the whisky priest might not be the spiritual leaders she wants, but they are the only ones she has.