It’s possible to situate
Gilly Hopkins—and Paterson’s realist children’s novels as a group—as part of a midcentury movement toward including realism and difficult themes in children’s novels. Natalie Babbit’s 1975 novel
Tuck Everlasting deals frankly with death.
Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret, Judy Blume’s 1970 classic, tackles puberty. And Lois Lowry’s debut novel from the same year,
A Summer to Die, features a family dealing with the older daughter’s childhood leukemia diagnosis and death from the disease. It’s possible to see how this genre of “issue novels” has continued to evolve over time, and as issues change.
Monday’s Not Coming, for instance, a 2018 novel by Tiffany Jackson inspired by real events, deals with child abuse, filicide, and the dangers of bureaucratic failures, particularly to poor Black girls in the United States. Gary Schmidt’s
Orbiting Jupiter, like
Gilly Hopkins, explores the U.S. foster care system, including its limits when it comes to its ability to protect children. Within the novel itself, Gilly’s full name, Galadriel, comes from J. R. R. Tolkien’s classic
Lord of the Rings series, while she and Mr. Randolph enjoy William Wordsworth’s poem “Ode: Imitations of Immortality from Recollections of Early Childhood.”